Hollywood’s Golden Age may be remembered for its glamour, but for Asian actors, it was an era of exclusion. This article uncovers Hollywood’s use of yellowface and how it shaped the long battle for Asian representation in Hollywood.
Instead of hiring real Asian talent, Hollywood doubled down on yellowface—the practice of casting white actors in Asian roles while using makeup, tape, and prosthetics to alter their appearance. These roles often portrayed Asians as either sinister villains, submissive women, or comic relief, reinforcing deeply harmful stereotypes.
Today, we recognize these films as problematic. But at the time, Hollywood awarded Oscars to yellowface performances and actively denied Asian actors the chance to play themselves. The impact of this discrimination lasted decades, keeping Asian actors out of leading roles and affecting their careers even after the Golden Age ended.
Let’s take a deep dive into Hollywood’s most infamous yellowface films, why it happened, and the long-term damage it caused.
The Yellowface Hall of Shame: Hollywood’s Repeat Offenders
Some of the biggest stars of the Golden Age of Hollywood donned tape, wigs, and exaggerated accents to play Asian characters. This was not Asian representation in Hollywood. This was whitewashing. These performances weren’t just offensive—they shaped how audiences perceived Asian people for generations.
1. Luise Rainer in The Good Earth (1937)
- What Happened? MGM’s The Good Earth was based on Pearl S. Buck’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel about Chinese farmers. The lead role of O-Lan went to Luise Rainer, a German actress, while Paul Muni, another white actor, played her husband.
- Why It’s Problematic: Hollywood had Asian actresses available—most notably Anna May Wong, a major star at the time. But Wong was denied the role because of anti-miscegenation laws, which prohibited interracial romance on screen. Since Muni was white, casting Wong as his wife was out of the question.
- The Fallout: Rainer won the Academy Award for Best Actress, further proving that Hollywood was willing to reward white actors for Asian roles but refused to cast real Asian talent.
2. Katharine Hepburn in Dragon Seed (1944)
- What Happened? Hepburn, one of Hollywood’s most celebrated actresses, starred as Jade, a Chinese woman resisting Japanese invaders in WWII.
- Why It’s Problematic: The film relied on heavy makeup, prosthetics, and forced accents to transform white actors into “Asian” characters. While the movie attempted to depict the struggle of the Chinese people, it failed to actually include them.
- The Fallout: The film bombed at the box office and was widely mocked, but it remains one of the most egregious examples of Hollywood’s refusal to cast Asian leads—even in roles that celebrated Asian resistance.
3. Marlon Brando in The Teahouse of the August Moon (1956)
- What Happened? Brando played Sakini, an Okinawan interpreter, in this “lighthearted” post-WWII comedy.
- Why It’s Problematic: Brando’s performance was cartoonish, with exaggerated facial expressions and an embarrassingly bad “Asian” accent. This film was released a decade after the war, at a time when Japanese Americans were still recovering from forced internment camps—yet Hollywood thought this caricature was appropriate.
- The Fallout: This film wasn’t Brando’s finest moment, and critics today regard it as one of Hollywood’s most misguided casting choices.
4. John Wayne in The Conqueror (1956)
- What Happened? John Wayne, the ultimate symbol of rugged American masculinity, played Genghis Khan—a historical Mongolian ruler.
- Why It’s Problematic: To make Wayne look “Mongolian,” makeup artists bronzed his skin, reshaped his eyes, and altered his hairline—but nothing could hide the fact that he still spoke like a cowboy. The film was a disaster.
- The Fallout: The film was both a box-office and critical failure, with many considering it one of the worst movies ever made. Even Wayne later admitted he was completely miscast.
Why Did Hollywood Keep Doing This?
Yellowface wasn’t just bad casting—it was systemic discrimination. Hollywood had plenty of excuses, none of which hold up.
📌 “No Marketable Asian Stars”
- Studios claimed audiences wouldn’t pay to see an Asian lead, but this was a blatant lie.
- Sessue Hayakawa was a silent film heartthrob, and Anna May Wong was internationally famous.
- Asian actors were only unmarketable because Hollywood refused to give them a chance.
📌 Anti-Miscegenation Laws
- Interracial romance was illegal on screen in many states.
- Since Hollywood’s leading men were usually white, that meant Asian actresses were blocked from playing romantic roles.
- Instead, Hollywood cast white women as Asian women, ensuring they could pair them with white male leads.
📌 Exoticism and Stereotypes
- Hollywood wasn’t interested in real Asian stories—it wanted exotic fantasy not authentic Asian Representation in Hollywood.
- Instead of casting authentically, studios relied on white actors in over-the-top costumes to create Western-friendly versions of Asia.
The Cost: The Asian Stars Hollywood Rejected
While Hollywood handed out Oscars to white actors in yellowface, Asian Representation in Hollywood continued to struggle with real Asian actors struggling to get roles.
🎭 Anna May Wong – Denied lead roles, she was forced to play dragon ladies and side characters. Eventually, she left for Europe, frustrated by Hollywood’s racism.
🎭 Philip Ahn – Born in LA, Ahn was cast as villains or servants while white actors took starring roles.
🎭 Keye Luke – Best known as Kato in The Green Hornet, Luke was rarely allowed to be more than a supporting player.
These actors paved the way for future generations, but Hollywood’s racism stunted their careers and kept Asian actors in the margins for decades.
The Aftermath: When Did Yellowface End?
Spoiler: It didn’t.
Even after the Golden Age, Hollywood continued whitewashing Asian roles and fighting against Asian Representation in Hollywood:
🔸 Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany’s (1961)
- One of the most offensive portrayals of an Asian character in film history. Rooney played Mr. Yunioshi, a Japanese landlord, with buck teeth, taped eyelids, and an exaggerated accent that turned the character into a racist caricature.
- Even director Blake Edwards later admitted the role was a mistake, but the damage had been done.
🔸 David Carradine in Kung Fu (1972-1975)
- This TV show was originally conceived by Bruce Lee, who pitched the idea about a Chinese martial artist in the Old West.
- Instead of casting Lee, Hollywood gave the role to David Carradine, a white actor who used makeup and slow speech to imitate an Asian persona.
- The irony? Bruce Lee was deemed “too Asian” for the lead role—in a show he created.
Modern Whitewashing Scandals
🔸 Emma Stone in Aloha (2015)
- Stone played Allison Ng, a character explicitly written as part Chinese and part Hawaiian—despite Stone being a white actress with no Asian heritage.
- The backlash was immediate, and even Stone later admitted the casting was a mistake and acknowledged the lack of Asian Representation in Hollywood.
🔸 Scarlett Johansson in Ghost in the Shell (2017)
- Johansson played Motoko Kusanagi, a Japanese cyborg in a film based on a classic Japanese manga and anime.
- The film’s visuals and setting were entirely Japanese, making the casting of a white actress even more glaring.
- Critics noted that CGI was reportedly tested to “digitally Asianify” Johansson, which only fueled more outrage.
🔸 Tilda Swinton in Doctor Strange (2016)
- Swinton played The Ancient One, a character that was originally a Tibetan monk in Marvel Comics.
- Marvel changed the character’s ethnicity to a white, Celtic mystic to avoid backlash from China (due to political tensions with Tibet).
- This move erased an Asian character from a major franchise, replacing them with a white actor under the guise of avoiding stereotypes.
🔸 The Entire Cast of The Last Airbender (2010)
- The beloved animated series Avatar: The Last Airbender is rooted in Asian and Inuit cultures, featuring characters inspired by Chinese, Japanese, and Indigenous traditions.
- However, the live-action adaptation cast mostly white actors in the leading roles of Aang, Katara, and Sokka, while the villains were played by darker-skinned actors—a decision that many criticized as reinforcing harmful stereotypes.
- This movie became one of the most infamous whitewashing examples in recent history.
🔸 Matt Damon in The Great Wall (2016)
- A Hollywood-produced Chinese epic that still cast a white actor as the savior of ancient China.
- The film’s marketing implied that only Matt Damon’s character could stop the invasion, which led to accusations of the “white savior” trope.
🔸 Benedict Cumberbatch in Star Trek Into Darkness (2013)
- Cumberbatch played Khan Noonien Singh, a role originally played by Mexican actor Ricardo Montalbán.
- While Montalbán’s casting wasn’t perfect either, Khan was always depicted as a South Asian character.
- Instead of casting an actual South Asian actor, the role was given to a British white actor, erasing an opportunity for proper representation.
It took over a century for Hollywood to embrace Asian talent, but thanks to those who fought for change, we’re finally seeing progress.
Asian Representation in Hollywood: Asian Actors and Filmmakers by the numbers
The Academy Awards have ignored Asian representation in Hollywood but times have been changing but definitely not enough to make a significant and lasting impact.
Notable milestones include:
- Miyoshi Umeki – In 1958, she became the first Asian actor to win an Oscar, earning Best Supporting Actress for Sayonara.
- Haing S. Ngor – Won Best Supporting Actor in 1985 for The Killing Fields.
- Ang Lee – The Taiwanese director won Best Director twice, for Brokeback Mountain (2005) and Life of Pi (2012).
- Chloé Zhao – Made history in 2021 as the first Asian woman to win Best Director for Nomadland.
- Youn Yuh-jung – In 2021, she became the first Korean actress to win an Oscar, taking home Best Supporting Actress for Minari. She was also only the second Asian actress ever to win in an acting category, following Miyoshi Umeki in 1958.
- Ke Huy Quan – In 2023, he became the first Vietnamese-born actor to win an Academy Award, earning Best Supporting Actor for Everything Everywhere All at Once. After being shut out of Hollywood for decades, his comeback win symbolized both progress and the industry’s long-standing exclusion of Asian talent.
- Michelle Yeoh – In 2023, she became the first Asian woman to win Best Actress for Everything Everywhere All at Once, making history after nearly a century of Asian women being overlooked.
The Numbers: the disparity of Asian Representation in Hollywood
- White actors have won over 90% of acting Oscars since the Academy Awards began in 1929.
- Actors of Asian descent make up less than 1% of all acting wins in Oscar history.
- Asian filmmakers have won more awards in non-acting categories (such as Best Director or Best Picture), but still face disproportionate hurdles compared to their white counterparts.
While Asian Representation in Hollywood continues to be an upward climb, South Korea has gained more recognition in Hollywood in recent years, especially after Parasite (2019) became the first Korean film to win Best Picture, Asian actors and filmmakers still fight for fair representation and recognition.
Final Thoughts: The Lasting Impact of Yellowface
The Golden Age of Hollywood is often remembered as a glamorous, magical era, but behind the scenes, it was deeply exclusionary. Asian actors lost opportunities, their stories were rewritten, and white actors were rewarded for playing roles that never belonged to them.
As we celebrate classic films, we also have to acknowledge their failures. Because when you see a white actor playing an Asian character, the real question is: Who should have been in that role instead?
Follow us on Instagram or drop us a note as we continue this discussion.